Teresa Burkholder
B: 1960-11-03
D: 2019-08-17
View Details
Burkholder, Teresa
Dorothy Cressler
B: 1921-01-28
D: 2019-08-15
View Details
Cressler, Dorothy
Gerda Gleim
B: 1923-12-11
D: 2019-08-12
View Details
Gleim, Gerda
Rev. John Loewen
B: 1925-11-01
D: 2019-08-11
View Details
Loewen, Rev. John
Ruth Brenize
B: 1931-01-13
D: 2019-08-10
View Details
Brenize, Ruth
John Bonitz
B: 1928-01-03
D: 2019-08-10
View Details
Bonitz, John
Charles Beltz
B: 1931-04-10
D: 2019-08-08
View Details
Beltz, Charles
Martha Gayman
B: 1927-09-14
D: 2019-08-06
View Details
Gayman, Martha
John Guyer
B: 1928-10-23
D: 2019-08-06
View Details
Guyer, John
Darcy Mowers
B: 1953-11-29
D: 2019-08-05
View Details
Mowers, Darcy
Douglas Bair
B: 1968-01-19
D: 2019-08-02
View Details
Bair, Douglas
Jean Clugh
B: 1932-02-02
D: 2019-07-29
View Details
Clugh, Jean
Roxanna Sheaffer
B: 1945-04-16
D: 2019-07-24
View Details
Sheaffer, Roxanna
Ralph Weaver
B: 1941-12-30
D: 2019-07-23
View Details
Weaver, Ralph
Donald Stine
B: 1931-12-26
D: 2019-07-23
View Details
Stine, Donald
William Curtis
B: 1945-01-17
D: 2019-07-20
View Details
Curtis, William
Lawrence Ciccia
B: 1959-11-09
D: 2019-07-19
View Details
Ciccia, Lawrence
Richard Hurley
B: 1940-01-10
D: 2019-07-16
View Details
Hurley, Richard
Marian Lavine
B: 1920-12-07
D: 2019-07-15
View Details
Lavine, Marian
Richard Martin
B: 1946-05-12
D: 2019-07-14
View Details
Martin, Richard
Vera Rosenberry
B: 1926-04-06
D: 2019-07-13
View Details
Rosenberry, Vera


Use the form above to find your loved one. You can search using the name of your loved one, or any family name for current or past services entrusted to our firm.

Click here to view all obituaries
Search Obituaries
112 West King Street
P.O. Box 336
Shippensburg, PA 17257
Phone: 717-532-2211
Fax: 717-532-8471
Mary Fay

Mary Jane Fay (Reehil)

Friday, May 22nd, 1931 - Monday, April 29th, 2019
Recommend this to your friends.
Share via:

Sign in to the Family Interactive Login

The Family Interactive feature enhances An Amazing Life. Authorized family members can securely access their loved one's memorial website settings at any time.

Share Book of Memories with a Friend

Please enter the name and email details so that we can send your friend a link to the online tribute. No names or addresses will be collected by using this service.

Email Sent

Your email has been sent.

To share your memory on the wall of Mary Fay, sign in using one of the following options:

Sign in with Facebook


Or sign in with your email address

Your condolence has been posted successfully

Provide comfort for the family of Mary Fay with a meaningful gesture of sympathy.

No Thanks

Contact Funeral Home

Please enter your question / comment below:

Email Sent

Your email has been sent.


Mary Jane Fay (nee Reehil), died Monday April 29, 2019 in Mechanicsburg, PA. Mary Jane was born May 22, 1931 in Queens Village, NY. She was the daughter of John & Ruth Reehil and the widow of William J. Fay. Mary Jane graduated from Bishop McDonnell High School in Brooklyn NY, SUNY at New Paltz (undergraduate), and Shippensburg University where she obtained her masters degree while teaching 2nd grade in the Shippensburg Area School District by day, and going to school in the evening, with eight children at home! She was a hard-working, compassionate, intelligent, and beautiful woman.

Mary Jane and Bill were married in 1952 and spent the next 28 years together, he was the love of her life. Mary Jane was a widow too young and also had the immense sorrow of the deaths of her sons, William D. Fay, Kieran F. Fay, eldest daughter, Janemarie Fay and last year, her beloved eldest grandson, William J. Fay II. Despite these losses, Mary Jane was always a bright light, great conversationalist, quick wit, wonderful mother, and frequently present grandmother. She spent many happy hours with her grandchildren, listening and encouraging them, and in her “teacher mode”, having them draw pictures of any story they wanted to tell, then carefully transcribing their stories onto paper. Showing them not only how to physically write, but how to tell a story. She was a gem.

Mary Jane was a school teacher for many years, both in New York and Pennsylvania. She spent the majority of those years teaching 2nd grade in the Shippensburg Area School District (JW Kline, James Burd Elementary). She was a requiring, fair and kind teacher to all of her students. For many years she would see former students around town and would often hear, “hi Mrs. Fay, do you remember me?” and she always did.
A few of Mary Jane’s professional accomplishments include; member and former president of the civic club, Democratic committee woman, and chief negotiator representing the local teacher’s union. Her skills of graciousness, respectfulness, intellect and tact were her super powers.

Mary Jane is survived by her children Christopher Fay (Orlando, FL), Brian Fay (Ruth Moore) (York), Kerri Fay (Michael Harants) (Mechanicsburg), Maura Cohen (Larry) (Mechanicsburg) and Tara Fay (Shippensburg); grandchildren Mara Hollis (Joe) (Lexington KY), Benjamin Cohen, Lily Harants, Elizabeth Cohen, Evan Harants: and great-grandchildren Morgann Fay and Grace Hollis. Two sisters: Ann Reehil (Fort Myers FL) and Margaret Reehil (Holly Hills, Fl). In addition to her parents, she was preceded in death by her brothers Peter, Paul, and sister Antionette.

A funeral mass celebrating Mary Jane’s wonderful life, will be on Saturday, June 8, 2019 at 11am at Our Lady of the Visitation, Catholic Church, Shippensburg PA. Visitation will begin one-hour preceding mass. In lieu of flowers, donations may be made in memory of Mary Jane to the Peyton Walker Foundation, PO Box 1482, Mechanicsburg, PA 17055.

Online condolences may be expressed at
Read Less

Service Details

  • Visitation

    Saturday, June 8th, 2019 | 10:00am - 11:00am
    Saturday, June 8th, 2019 10:00am - 11:00am
    Our Lady of the Visitation Catholic Church
    305 North Prince Street
    shippensburg, PA 17257
    Get Directions: View Map | Text | Email
  • Service

    Saturday, June 8th, 2019 | 11:00am
    Saturday, June 8th, 2019 11:00am
    Our Lady of the Visitation Catholic Church
    305 North Prince Street
    shippensburg, PA 17257
    Get Directions: View Map | Text | Email
    Father Dwight D. Schlaline
  • Interment

    Long Island National Cemetery
    2040 Wellwood Avenue
    WYANDANCH, NY 11798
    Get Directions: View Map | Text | Email

Purchase Flowers

Consider providing a gift of comfort for the family of Mary Fay by sending flowers.

Purchase Flowers


We encourage you to share your most beloved memories of Mary here, so that the family and other loved ones can always see it. You can upload cherished photographs, or share your favorite stories, and can even comment on those shared by others.

Private Condolence

Tracy Coover

Posted at 01:25pm
My sympathy to Brian and family.

Dottie M.

Posted at 08:23pm
Mary was a beautiful, kind, compassionate woman. I enjoyed teaching with her at James Burd Elementary School.

Rex Lord

Posted at 04:06pm
Mary Fay was a great woman and mother. I will always remember Mary Fay. She was always a very fine person with an understated but very clear sense of humor. The world is a lesser place with Mary Jane Fay no longer with us. The Fay family is in my prayers.

Sharon Raubenstine

Posted at 10:48am
Mary Fay hired me as the school clerk for J.W.Kline School. I worked with her for many years. She was a wonderful lady. She loved her students and I will never forget the friendship I had with her. Prayers for the whole family.

Randall Tenor

Posted at 03:34pm
Our deepest sympathies to Mary Jane’s family. We remember seeing her at family celebrations, she was a very sweet lady. Sincerely, Sue, Randy and Greg Tenor

Photos & Videos

Photo Album